Green Guide for Sears
Sears has around than 2200 stores nationwide and does over $20 billion in sales each year.
Sears has greatly improved its reporting since the last time we conducted our analysis, although we were still not able to find its carbon footprint publicly reported. Sears is also one of the few retailers that has completely phased out PVC from its packaging. Sears has joined the Responsible Appliance Disposal (RAD) Program which offers a take-back program for consumers. Sears has around 180 stores that are Energy Star certified, and has a SmartWay certified transportation fleet. Also, most of its transportation mileage is through rail which is environmentally preferable to truck fleets.
We could not find any information to suggest that Sears has yet to utilize any significant amounts of renewable energy, which is something we would love to see in the future. Sears also seems to be lagging a bit in terms of green product offerings. Sears does sell a wide variety of Energy Star certified products, but we would like to see more green products offered such as products made from organic or natural materials, or FSC-certified products, for example.
Sears is our most improved big box retailer for our 2011 update, gets its first Greenopia leaf, and is right on the cusp of getting 2 leafs. We hope to see them keep up the awesome work!
Even though we here at Greenopia are all about supporting local green businesses, sometimes we find ourselves in situations where we have to shop at a large national retailer. As you may imagine, there is a lot of variation in the environmental performance amongst the biggest retailers in the U.S., so we have scoured their sustainability reports, certifications, and other sources to collect information regarding their greenness.
One thing to point out is that the way we rate these companies (explained in more detail below) is not the same as our local business ratings. To put it simply, national chains would not be able to meet the rigorous criteria that we use to analyze smaller businesses (except a select few, who we already list). And, we also have to keep in mind that it is not realistic for us to assume a national chain can become green overnight. They have much more complicated supply chains and larger stores to deal with than smaller, local businesses. But, since chains have a larger overall impact, it is important that they become green and we want to support the chains that are going the extra mile.
Thus in the spirit of providing the best green information we can, we have awarded a leaf rating and description of some of largest retailers in the US showing if they are green and how they can improve. We have also created a scorecard with various icons showcasing the specific areas in which the corporations excel relative to the rest of the industry.
Our leaf awards are based on the following:
- Green Building Design
- Supply Chain
- Recycling/Take-Back Programs
- Sustainability Reporting
- Green Power
- Some Notable Environmental Initiatives or a Dedicated Light Green Brand.
- Solid Environmental Initiatives.
- A Very Strong Environmental Commitments.
- An Environmental Leader in this Industry.
Oftentimes a sustainability report is the only way for the general public to easily track down environmental information about large corporations. In reality, only a few companies take the time to publish sustainability reports every 1-2 years and even fewer publish reports of any true value. We scored companies based off how thorough their environmental reporting was. Also, for us to consider something a sustainability report, it had to be updated at least every 2 years, set clear environmental goals for the company, and track their progress over time in several environmental indicators. In order to receive this icon on their scorecard, a company had to meet 75% of the criteria in this category.
Green Building Design
There are a variety of things that companies are doing to green their buildings ranging from some minor improvements like using energy efficient light bulbs and/or fixtures to more dedicated efforts like building green stores, requiring that every new store meets LEED standards, or powering a large number of their stores with renewable energy. Companies were given points based off the green building design elements they were incorporating into their present and future stores. Companies receiving this icon on their scorecard met at least 50% of our criteria in this category.
Certain retailers have different standards for their vendors. Some just care whether or not the vendor is in basic environmental compliance, while others go as far as to work with vendors to redesign packaging or to only work with vendors who are have a stellar environmental track record. We know that refining a supply chain takes a lot of time and money so we wanted to promote the firms that are making this effort. Chains were rated by how much they have done to green their supply chain. Companies receiving this icon on their scorecard met at least 50% of our criteria in this category.
Recycling/Take-Back Programs - Did not Qualify
At this point, recycling things like office paper is trivial, almost everyone does it. But it is much rarer for stores to offer take-back programs for the products they sell that may contain hazardous inputs. And to those who claim that retailers shouldn't be the ones to carry this cost, don't forget that retailers profit off the sales of these items too and some have already taken the initiative to be responsible for these items (and don't worry, we hold manufacturers accountable for take-back in our product ratings as well). Companies were given points depending on how thorough and widespread their take-back efforts were. Companies receiving this icon on their scorecard met at least 50% of our criteria in this category.
Stock - Did not Qualify
It's important to note how many green products a company buys and sells. We gave companies points based off the percentage of green products that they carried. Companies receiving this icon on their scorecard met at least 50% of our criteria in this category (This is not the same as saying 50% of their stock was green; we instead looked at how many green brands companies offered and if they were promoted in a special way).
Green Power - Did not Qualify
Companies have begun to utilize renewable energy in a variety of ways. On a small scale, some chains have solar panels on a few stores in favorable climates, others purchase offsets for their energy footprint, and others use renewable energy from local providers. In our mathematical ratings, this criterion was considered under the green building design category, but no scorecard icon was given.